Independent Retailers in Canada Hit with High Job Vacancies and Higher Property Taxes: CFIB

By Dan Kelly, President and CEO of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business

Independent retailers don’t always get the recognition they deserve for the many contributions they make to their communities and to Canada. They provide young people with their first work opportunities, they grow the Canadian economy and they often sponsor local charities and sports teams. And yet, many smaller retailers are having a harder time staying competitive.

Retailers are, on average, less optimistic about the overall health of their business than other business owners, according to the Canadian Federation of Independent Business (CFIB)’s monthly Business Barometer. The shortage of skilled labour is one of the top factors hindering their growth.

Our business counsellors are increasingly getting calls from CFIB members who are struggling to find the right candidates and who are asking for guidance on filling jobs. In the first quarter of 2019, 58,700 retail jobs sat vacant for at least four months, according to our latest Help Wanted report. In fact, the vacancy rate in retail has been steadily growing since 2016. A vacant job means longer wait times for customers, a heavier load on other employees – and often on the owner themselves.

Côte-des-Neiges in Montreal. Photo: @lvbs via InstagramCôte-des-Neiges in Montreal. Photo: @lvbs via Instagram

Côte-des-Neiges in Montreal. Photo: @lvbs via Instagram

Employers know that it’s never as simple as just putting a warm body in the job. They need employees with the right combination of skills and attitude – something that’s proving difficult to find. Young employees, especially, can take up a lot of time as they need more training in soft skills, like punctuality, communicating professionally and following workplace safety guidelines.

CFIB has been asking governments to recognize the training employers provide young workers by introducing an Employment Insurance (EI) training credit. Universities, colleges and high schools should also focus on creating more workplace-integrated opportunities that connect young people with small businesses. These are just a few measures that could help small firms compete with big business and government for a shrinking pool of qualified candidates.

And while it’s hard to highlight just one of the many taxes small business owners pay, CFIB has increasingly been hearing from bricks-and-mortar retailers that rising property taxes are a major impediment to their ability to stay profitable. The issue came to a head this summer in Calgary, where thousands of business owners protested the city’s decision to increase commercial property taxes by a staggering 10 to 30 per cent. The protest got the city to back down from the increase, but the fight isn’t over. Calgary is far from the only municipality where this is a problem.

Commercial Drive in Vancouver. Photo: Liv RentCommercial Drive in Vancouver. Photo: Liv Rent

Commercial Drive in Vancouver. Photo: Liv Rent

In fact, as you likely know from looking at your tax bill, nearly all local governments tax commercial properties at much higher rates than residential properties – up to nearly 5 times higher in some jurisdictions. On top of that, many provincial governments apply higher education taxes on commercial properties than residential properties. A more equal and fair distribution of property taxes between residents and businesses would help create a competitive environment for local merchants and encourage entrepreneurship.

Governments can do much to improve both of these issues for small retailers, but they won’t do it unless they’re pushed. Unfortunately, small business owners rarely have the time or resources to fight for themselves. This is where business associations can help by uniting and amplifying the voices of independent retailers and working on their behalf to demand better.

CFIB’s credit card fight is a great example of this. About a decade ago, our members told us they were being charged astronomical fees on credit card transactions, especially with the rise of rewards cards. While the big guys were able to negotiate better deals with the major credit cards, independent retailers were stuck with unfair contracts and usurious rates.

17th Avenue in Calgary. RENDERING: City of Calgary17th Avenue in Calgary. RENDERING: City of Calgary

17th Avenue in Calgary. RENDERING: City of Calgary

But with the collective bargaining power of more than 100,000 members, we were able to negotiate better rates for all small businesses and exclusive savings for CFIB members with Mastercard and American Express. We also convinced the government to implement a Code of Conduct for the payments industry. While work remains to be done on the credit card file, we have certainly come a long way.

I encourage independent retailers dealing with problems like these to look to their community of business owners for support and join a business association. CFIB brings its members’ views directly to government, and we also offer expert advice on HR issues and government regulation, as well as exclusive savings on essential services like payment processing, banking and payroll management. There is strength in numbers and by joining together, small business can have a big impact. Visit for more information.


Dan Kelly is President and Chief Executive Officer of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, Canada’s largest association of small and medium-sized businesses with 110,000 members across every industry and region.

Article Author

Craig Patterson
Craig Patterson
Now located in Toronto, Craig is a retail analyst and consultant at the Retail Council of Canada. He's also the Director of Applied Research at the University of Alberta School of Retailing in Edmonton. He has studied the Canadian retail landscape for the past 25 years and he holds Bachelor of Commerce and Bachelor of Laws Degrees. He is also President & CEO of Vancouver-based Retail Insider Media Ltd.

More From The Author

Exterior image of 745 Thurlow Street. Photo: MCMP Architects

Luxury Brand Thom Browne to Open 2nd Canadian Storefront in Vancouver

The NYC-based luxury brand will replace Versace in the city’s downtown ‘Luxury Zone’.
Exterior of a boarded up Harry Rosen in Yorkville - Photo taken by Craig Patterson Spring 2020

Hindsight 2020: Canadian Retail in the Rearview Window

A year unlike any other saw the retail industry transform amid an acceleration of trends and mass store closures.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Harry Rosen and Masai Ujiri Collaboration Provides Message of HUMANITY

Canada’s leading purveyor of menswear transcends its retail offering with a collection promoting equality and inclusivity.

Retailers Led Bankruptcy Filings in Canada Over the Past 12 Months: Insolvency Insider

The publication tracks filings and one editor says that they expect an increase in filings in early 2021 following rent payment demands from landlords.

McGill University Bensadoun Retail School & Couche-Tard Launch Unique Retail Innovation Laboratory

The future of retail innovation and customer experience is being tested in Canada amid significant changes to the industry.

SUBSCRIBE to Retail Insider's Daily E-News for Free:

* indicates required


International Retailers Continue to Enter Canadian Market Despite Pandemic [List/Analysis]

Retail Insider analysis of the international retailers that have entered Canada over the past 12 months as the industry looks to an uncertain future.

Canadian Footwear Brand Maguire Opens First Toronto Store

The Montreal company anticipates lower rents and as a result, plans to selectively open more locations while also significantly growing e-commerce.

M&M Food Market Continues Cross-Canada Store Expansion With New Partnerships

About 800 ‘express’ locations opened over the past year and several full-sized stores will be unveiled next year.
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -