Ontario Retail Shutdown Extension into January 2021 Will Cause Severe Harm to Industry: Experts

The Ontario government, in consultation with the Chief Medical Officer of Health, is extending all COVID-19 orders currently in force under the Reopening Ontario Act until January 20, 2021. 

The announcement came the same day (Thursday) that iconic Canadian retailer Hudson’s Bay issued a statement related to its application for a judicial review of the current regulations governing non-essential retail in Toronto and Peel.

Hudson’s Bay Calls for Judicial Review of Ontario COVID-19 Regulations

“The Ontario Government’s health data shows that retail shoppers are not contributing to COVID-19 spread in any significant way. On behalf of thousands of large and small retailers in Toronto and Peel, we have been left with no choice but to ask the Court to recognize the unfairness of the current situation and the need for a fair and evidence-based solution that puts health and safety first and doesn’t jeopardize the livelihoods of thousands of retail workers, or the future of many businesses,” said Hudson’s Bay.

“Last week we signed an open letter, along with 46 other retailers of various sizes, to advocate for a 25% capacity limit on all retailers across the province as a means to achieving better public health outcomes with less economic fallout and unfairness. The decision to close some retailers in these regions has not achieved public health objectives. Rather, it has potentially increased health risks by funnelling more shoppers into fewer, increasingly crowded stores. Public health evidence regarding the importance of physical spacing and other health measures supports doing the complete opposite.

“The Government’s approach is unreasonable and unfair, does not support our shared public health objectives and is causing undue stress and hardships to thousands of retail employees and businesses across the region. The situation is dire and untenable for thousands of retailers but it’s not too late for the Government to make a better decision for Ontario, the local economy, public health, and the millions of citizens who live or work in Toronto and Peel.”

In a statement, Solicitor General Sylvia Jones said safeguarding the health and well-being of Ontarians remains the government’s top priority at every stage of its COVID-19 response.

Bruce Winder
Bruce Winder

“As we prepare to implement a safe and effective immunization program, extending these orders will ensure tools remain in place to address urgent public health situations until all Ontarians can be vaccinated,” she said.

Bruce Winder, author of RETAIL Before, During & After COVID-19 and President of Bruce Winder Retail, said overall this will have less of an impact as January is a slow retail month.

“Having said that, there are some retailers such as those that sell fitness equipment and gyms that count on January as a prime sales/recruitment month. We could see crowds though at essential retailers as customers return products that were bought for the holidays,” he said.  

“Those non-essential retailers that participate in Boxing Day and Boxing week activities will be disadvantaged as will restaurants that use New Year’s Eve as a major sales driver.”

Dan Kelly, President and CEO of the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, said the organization is supportive of the principle behind the Bay’s lawsuit.

“Our preferred outcome is different than theirs but the principle behind saying Costco and Walmart can open and yet retailers cannot we support what the Bay is saying,” added Kelly. “It makes no sense to prohibit buying clothing at the Bay or Susan’s Ladieswear but to allow it at Costco and at Walmart. So we support the principles behind the Bay’s lawsuit.”

Gary Newbury, a retail supply chain strategist and serial transformation executive, said the alleged court action being mounted by The Bay to the government will be watched by many retailers to see the quality of the argument and any potential success. 
“If they are successful, which is unlikely, there will be a class action which could bankrupt the province. It has been a concern, with various federal schemes to help retailers through this situation, this is simply not adequate with too many retailers having to dip into their own funds and pockets to weather this storm,” he said.

“When the state imposes closure, there has to be some logic, just as when you cause damage to a neighbour’s property, you create a path to be liable for all reasonable consequential losses. If we think of it this way, the government is using emergency powers to “flatten the curve” on the demand for ICU services. One could argue the state should, through it’ pandemic planning protocols in previous years, thave established the requirements, in absolute numbers, for ICU wards for pandemic management and had a fiscal plan over several years to ensure their provision. If the governments in Ontario have chosen not to do this, then the closures, surely could be argued under the tort of negligence in which case, there is a risk of a substantial class action, and other provinces will be watching this situation develop.”

Newbury said any closures which impact any time between Black Friday through to the conclusion of January sales, including Boxing Day sales, will be devastating for any independent or chain retailers, not deemed “essential”. 

Gary Newbury
Gary Newbury

“This is traditionally a very busy time for retailers, in a normal year they would plan to make 80-90 percent of their profit during this short window, and given most were locked down for two to three months during March – May, they would have been looking forward to getting a clear run to try and regain their cash flow during this time,” he said. “For those retailers who have moved their operations to a split of online and in store, they will find the costs of processing returns prohibitive if they have to close their stores, especially if they have been offering free returns via the store channel. All they might be able to negotiate is a longer returns deadline. The challenge with this is consumers may be worried they will not be around to get their money back and be engaging their credit card companies to reverse the transactions due to situations beyond their control.

“After the investment many retailers, especially the independents have made in being COVID-19 secure, they will feel severely let down by the Ontario government. The extra protocols have had to be funded out of their own scant cash flow, but it would have been done on the basis that “at least we can keep trading as we enter the holiday peak”. This extension to 20th January will force many to shut up shop permanently while their “essentially classified” competitors will be seen to gain a free pass to the party. Although COVID-19 is a real risk for community spread, the medium-term consequences to society’s view of public spaces is going to be transformed substantially. Anyone given to a degree of nostalgia will not be wanting to visit main streets, strip plazas and malls full of boarded up store fronts and tumbleweed, worsening the situation for those that struggle through this localized retailing apocalypse.”

Recently an open letter to Doug Ford, Premier of Ontario, and Christine Elliott, Deputy Premier of Ontario and Minister of Health said:

Dan Kelly
Dan Kelly

“Dear Premier Ford and Minister Elliott, about 47 retailers, including the Bay, wrote that “Ontario’s policy of segregating ‘non-essential’ retailers from those deemed essential might actually be making things worse” for the economic recovery.”

Current Policies Push Canadian Consumers Towards Big Box Retailers

The letter said the current policy pushes more Canadian consumers to a handful of big box retailers and discount stores, thousands of small, independent and local stores sit shuttered, with their hands tied, even though many sell the very same goods.

Canadian retail businesses are being destroyed and tens of thousands of jobs are being lost. This, despite the fact that only 0.2 percent to 0.9 percent of recent weekly cases related to outbreaks have been associated with retail environments, according to the Government of Ontario’s own statistics, said the letter which was dated December 1. 

It added that retailers of all sizes are being forced to lay off good people in hundreds of stores closed by an ineffective policy. Rather than hire thousands of temporary workers to handle the holiday rush, so-called non-essential retailers will hire zero. Once lost, many of these jobs won’t return.

“We ask that you move immediately to open all retail in Ontario, and impose a 25 percent capacity limit on ‘non-essential’ retail in lockdown regions, just as several other provinces have done, all with guidance and support from public health officials. This will put fewer people in more stores, increasing safety for all. The current policy does the opposite,” said the letter. “Together with mandatory mask policies, social distancing, hand sanitization and the numerous other safety measures already in place, capacity limits can further reduce the potential for community spread while enabling more businesses to stay open across all regions during a make-or-break season for retail businesses. 

“Large and small retailers need each other to create a vibrant retail ecosystem. Collectively, we are asking that you join with us in common cause and a shared commitment to keeping Ontario families safe and secure through this extraordinarily challenging period. Capacity restrictions backed by strong social distancing and other safety measures already in place will deliver better health outcomes in a way that is effective, fair, saves jobs and supports local businesses and families.

“On behalf of our respective companies, members and all of the various businesses and individuals that depend on the retail sector for their livelihoods, your thoughtful consideration and bold leadership on this matter will be greatly appreciated.”

In a news release, the Ontario government said the extension of all orders currently in force will support the safe delivery of health care and other critical services until COVID-19 vaccines are approved and widely available.

The government said amendments to the ROA, which came into force December 4, permit indoor farmer’s markets that primarily sell groceries, to be open. For post-secondary institutions, the amendments increase the limit on the number of persons permitted in an instructional space at any one time for in-person instruction or in-person exams from 10 to 50 people for certain programs critical to supporting the health care workforce as set out in the order.

Article Author

Mario Toneguzzi
Mario Toneguzzi
Mario Toneguzzi, based in Calgary, has more than 40 years experience as a daily newspaper writer, columnist, and editor. He worked for 35 years at the Calgary Herald covering sports, crime, politics, health, faith, city and breaking news, and business. He now works on his own as a freelance writer and consultant in communications and media relations/training.

More From The Author

Wetaskiwin Mall. Photo: Google Images

How a Shopping Centre in Wetaskiwin Is Being Repurposed Amid a...

The shopping centre property strategy involves shifting gears to a mix of uses beyond just retail.
Online shopping

How the Pandemic Has Changed Consumer Expectations While Accelerating Ecommerce in...

An expert says that online retail can only grow so much amid an over-saturation of new businesses.

RECENT RETAIL INSIDER VIDEOS

19 COMMENTS

  1. I don’t want to appear heartless, as I know the pandemic has been brutal for everyone, especially small businesses. But at what point do we stop looking at the money and start thinking about people? A vaccine is rolling out starting next week. Let’s be real…How long will it take to trickle down to the average joe? If you’re thinking in terms of weeks, think again. I’ll consider myself lucky if I’m inoculated in time for Easter. That mean’s another 5 to 6 months of mask’s and social distancing. And because we live in a democratic society, we’ll have to deal with the anti-vaxxer’s, and their ability to prolong the life of the virus. People can start their businesses again, but only if they’re alive to do so. If you’re worried about your bottom line, try visiting an ER and look at those poor, helpless individuals on ventilators, who may or may not make it out. Opening a business is a risk. Opening a business during the second wave of a pandemic that has killed 1.5 million people and counting is an unnecessary risk.

    • for the last 9 months the government has only cared about the people. The economy has never mattered – because it plays well politically.

      but when the government spends the equivalent of $8 Million per life lost (most of whom are over 80) — Economics should matter, saddling future generous will debt.

      ( the US has spent over $4 Trillion or over $14 Million per life lost ) and more stimulus is coming.

      Life Insurance companies but a value on Human Life all the time..

      Locking down the elderly and the most vulnerable (would save the most lives)…. but keep the economy open.

    • If you think that “another 5 to 6 months of mask’s and social distancing” is gonna happen, then you might want to rethink that statement. The folks that make these vaccines will not say, with any certainty, that a) they will stop COVID b)they will prevent transmission of the virus. and people like the esteemed Dr. Fauci have said that the masking, etc. will continue, even with the vaccines.

    • Really now. . You are getting paid still and your family will not suffer for years will they mr don’t worry about your bottom line.
      . 02 % is not an issue so shutting it down completely destroys and causes more harm

  2. Costco, Walmart and NURSING HOMES, have been the culprits since March, in the spread of Covit 19, myself and many others have been writing Doug Ford, since May, trying to knock sense into him and his medical nuts. Of course to no avail. What they are doing to Ontario is so destructive and just unimaginable. Time for Doug to go, I guess, never thought I would say that, but I and so many are fed up, period. Extending Williams huge salary, has just shown, how this government operates. Cash cows are open only, and of course the two leading ones, send the profit south. Hopefully, a fast court action, will overturn this inept Government.

    • Problem is you can’t get Doug out the party and you can’t vote for any other party. Ford has become a Liberal, the Fiberals have become the NDP and the NDP has become socialist union types.
      The time to vote was when you joined the party and made your vote for the PC leader. But Elliot came second and she is right there with Doug and the rest of them who are so afraid they can’t think straight.

  3. I own a small women’s street front boutique for over 3decades on Queen St East. I know that our store is safer to shop in, than the big box stores. Where social distancing and making sure the masks are over people’s noses is impossible to in force. I see Currant pictures from Walmart and Costco. It breaks my heart to see the recklessness. In those locations. 2021 I may just give up. With the debt load the Government is creating.

    • I agree with you totally. It makes no sense at all and I along with many of my family and friends would rather shop in the smaller stores than the big box stores. The ‘powers to be’ seemed to just want to appease the ‘big boys’ with no regard for the smaller independent retailers. Wishing you all the best.

      • To be fair all of the other countries are doing the same thing allowing anyone who sells groceries to stay open?during lock downs.
        I do agree small business with the limited capacity rules posed no risk or very little.
        If they had stopped weddings and religious gatherings we would have a lot less spread

    • That is a lot of BS. I traveled this summer, I did not wear a mask and I am perfectly fine. I shopped, I went to restaurants, I went in two countries in Europe. There is absolutely no indication that masks are doing anything. Look at countries having mandatory masks for months including outside. They have the highest numbers: France, Italy, Spain. Aren’t you people tired to be told for almost a year what to do, and struggling to make it through the month?

    • Naive comment and easy to say from people whose families and future livelihood destroyed.
      All you government workers like teachers should get pay cuts if you think this is ok.
      If masks and social distancing work then having 5 people in a small business with masks , sanitizer and distancing poses no risk. Comments like shutting them all down is the risk

    • @Ben – completely true! The reason why I took the photo was because although Starbucks moved across the street, the location sits vacant and a ghost storefront. This was not the only spot in The Beaches that I found, but we’re seeing a lot of these retail locations where the former business moved out and the landlords are unable to secure a new tenant.

  4. “The Retail Apocalypse” started over 10 years ago… Covid-19 has just accelerated a lot of trends that have been in place for years.

    Hence the run on high technology stocks this year.

  5. Tbh, retail workers are stressed overwhelmed, and worried. Ppl are quitting leaving those left more stressed. Ppl traveling from red and grey zones arguing about protocol. Two weeks after Christmas, is slow some days sales just covering wages. Shut it down during this time rather than longer later

  6. Well all people with Brain cells & education understand this is ridiculous! This lockdown & full border closure unless testing should have been done last December period… total incompetence we have people standing around making 300,000/yr guaranteed telling everyone they have to lock down for 28 days. My only question as an industrial engineer w/MBA who has worked in the private sector would policy be the same if the shoe was on the other foot?

  7. During the first lockdown I wondered why the KrispyKreme is open yet the Jimmy’s Coffee right next door, with the same capacity and service is closed? Why is a US company that is not really ‘essential’ open, yet a Canadian company of the exact kind (other than much better coffee and not publicly traded…hmm) is not?
    Of course to me personally coffee is essential, so why not keep both or the Canadian one open?
    When I hear a politician make promises and say they’re supportive of Canadian independent businesses I roll my eyes. Yeah right…
    Speaking of Walmart – shares are doing exceptionally well. Go figure. Small independent businesses are of little value when it comes to lining the pockets of the rich.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

RECENT ARTICLES

Aesop Expanding Canadian Store Operations with Multiple Storefronts Over 12 Months

The brand could open as many as five Canadian boutiques this year amid an ongoing expansion that includes new markets.

Canadian Retail 2020 Winners and Losers: Ed Strapagiel Analysis

Strapagiel provides his yearly analysis of Canadian retail sales data from StatsCan.

Photo Tour: The Ever-Changing Sherwood Park Mall in Sherwood Park, Alberta

The shopping centre in suburban Edmonton has seen new tenants replace old ones after the demise of Target in Canada.

Subscribe

* indicates required
Get Connected

MOST-READ ARTICLES

International Retailers Continue to Enter Canadian Market Despite Pandemic [List/Analysis]

Retail Insider analysis of the international retailers that have entered Canada over the past 12 months as the industry looks to an uncertain future.

Canadian Footwear Brand Maguire Opens First Toronto Store

The Montreal company anticipates lower rents and as a result, plans to selectively open more locations while also significantly growing e-commerce.

Big Changes Coming for Canadian Grocery in 2021 and Beyond: Expert

Expansion of omnichannel development and greater use of predictive analytics and machine learning to help shape the grocery experience of tomorrow.
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -